When Coffee Helps and When It Hurts: What Science Reveals About the World’s Favorite Drink
Dubai – Qahwa World
Why can some people drink espresso like water while others end up sleepless and anxious? Scientists say it all comes down to biology, genetics, and how the body processes caffeine. A growing body of research shows that while coffee brings clear health benefits for many, it can also pose serious risks for others.
Mic the Vegan, a science communicator with a Master’s degree in Public Health, recently reviewed dozens of clinical studies exploring the full spectrum of coffee’s health effects—from heart health and mental well-being to dementia and gene-based metabolism. His analysis paints a nuanced picture of when coffee supports health—and when it does not. “I’m not a coffee hater or a coffee addict,” Mic said. “I just wanted to understand why I react so strongly to coffee, and the science behind it.”
The Stimulant Effect: Energy, Focus, and Anxiety
Caffeine blocks adenosine, the chemical that makes us sleepy, while boosting dopamine and adrenaline levels. This combination explains why coffee is the world’s most consumed stimulant. A randomized crossover trial found that participants walked an average of 1,000 more steps per day when drinking coffee, a behavioral boost that may partly explain why moderate coffee drinkers experience lower cardiovascular mortality. Coffee also improves reaction time, processing speed, and alertness—so much so that even e-sports players perform better after caffeine. Yet overstimulation has a cost. High caffeine doses can trigger anxiety or panic attacks in sensitive individuals. Mic himself admits to “a little spice of anxiety” after several cups. One promising solution is L-theanine, a calming amino acid found in green tea. In studies, combining 100 mg of L-theanine with caffeine reduced anxiety while preserving focus.
Heart Health: A Double-Edged Sword
Across large population studies, moderate coffee intake—typically two to three cups per day—is linked with a 10–20% reduction in overall mortality. Among people who have survived a heart attack, those drinking two or more cups daily saw up to a 40% lower risk of death. Scientists attribute this benefit to coffee’s high antioxidant content, which may reduce arterial inflammation. However, not everyone benefits. Cardiologists at the Cleveland Clinic note that a morning cup can raise blood pressure by up to 10 points, enough to push some hypertensive patients into a danger zone. For individuals with grade 2–3 hypertension, an American Heart Association study found that drinking two or three cups per day doubled cardiovascular mortality risk. Excess caffeine can also constrict blood vessels. A 250 mg dose (about a large café serving) can cut cerebral blood flow by 22–30%, though regular drinkers appear to adapt over time. Interestingly, caffeine withdrawal temporarily increases blood flow, which may explain caffeine-withdrawal headaches.
Mental Health and Brain Function
Coffee’s link with mental health is complex. On one hand, high caffeine intake can heighten anxiety; on the other, moderate consumption is consistently associated with lower rates of depression. Studies suggest that people who drink two or more cups daily have a 32% lower prevalence of depression compared with non-drinkers. When it comes to long-term brain health, the evidence is mixed. A major meta-analysis found no significant change in overall dementia risk, but coffee drinkers showed nearly a 30% lower risk of Alzheimer’s disease. Another study, however, linked six or more cups per day—both caffeinated and decaf—with a 50% higher risk of dementia. Scientists caution that very high consumption may have cumulative vascular effects.
View this post on Instagram
Genes That Decide Whether Coffee Helps or Hurts
The liver enzyme gene CYP1A2 determines how quickly the body breaks down caffeine. Slow metabolizers have a two-fold higher risk of heart attack if they drink two or more cups daily. They are also more prone to insomnia and anxiety. Mic analyzed his own DNA and found he is an intermediate metabolizer (AC variant)—not highly tolerant but not overly sensitive. Another gene, ADORA2A, influences how caffeine affects sleep and mood, further explaining why coffee tolerance varies widely among individuals.
Beyond the Cup: Other Health Findings
Despite popular belief, large population studies show no clear association between coffee and acid reflux. Increasing coffee intake by just one cup a day was associated with an 11% lower risk of developing type 2 diabetes. Results are mixed regarding obesity—some trials found coffee improved body composition, while others reported increased cravings for sweets. Adding cream or cow’s milk can reduce coffee’s antioxidant and longevity benefits; black or plant-based coffee maintains them. Early 2025 research observed higher levels of Locinobacter saccharolyticus, a beneficial butyrate-producing bacterium, in coffee drinkers, though findings remain preliminary.
The Verdict: It Depends on You
On average, moderate coffee consumption appears beneficial—boosting cognition, protecting against depression, and supporting longevity. But for people with high blood pressure, slow caffeine metabolism, or heavy daily intake, risks may outweigh rewards. The healthiest approach is simple: keep it black or plant-based, limit intake to two or three cups daily, enjoy it in the morning, and pair it with L-theanine if you’re sensitive to caffeine. “Twice the risk of heart disease if you don’t have the right caffeine metabolism genes—that just blows my mind,” Mic concludes. Coffee, it turns out, is not universally good or bad. It’s a potent, plant-based stimulant—one that rewards moderation, respect, and understanding of your own biology before you pour the next cup.
